|
SUPTS. MEMO. NO. 2
July 24, 1998 |
| TO: | Division Superintendents |
| FROM: | Paul D. Stapleton
Superintendent of Public Instruction |
| SUBJECT: | Accreditation Issues |
This memorandum clarifies three issues related to the Regulations Establishing Standards for Accrediting Public Schools in Virginia adopted by the Board of Education in September 1997: 1) application of the new graduation requirements; 2) the removal of grades for credit- bearing courses taken in middle school; and 3) waivers of the standards. GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS A. Course and Units of Credit Requirements The new course and units of credit requirements for graduation outlined in the accrediting standards take effect with the ninth-grade class of 1998-99 (the graduating class of 2002). These requirements also apply to students who 1) are repeating the ninth grade, and 2) are classified as ungraded because of failure to pass all parts of the Literacy Passport Test (LPT), but otherwise would be classified as ninth-graders. Previous versions of the standards included a provision that "Graduation requirements for students shall be those in effect at the time the student entered the ninth grade." The new standards do not contain such a provision. Issues related to the promotion and retention of students, at any grade level, are governed by local school board policies. There is no statewide policy governing these practices. In addition, grade-level classification is governed by local policy with the exception of those students who continue to be required to pass the Literacy Passport Test (LPT) to be classified as ninth-graders or above. B. Verified Credit Requirements Verified units of credit requirements as outlined in the accrediting standards take effect beginning with the ninth-grade class of 2000-01 (the graduating class of 2004). The following exceptions should be noted: Students who were in grade nine in school year 1999-00 and are retained in grade nine (second-time ninth-graders in 2000-01) will not be held to the requirement of verified units of credit, but will continue with the LPT requirement for graduation. Similarly, any student in grade nine when the LPT graduation requirement was in effect but was retained in such a manner as to "fail back" into the verified credit cohort of students will continue with the LPT graduation requirement. Students classified as ungraded because of failure to pass all parts of the LPT, but who would otherwise be classified as ninth-grade or above, should be treated in the same manner as the "fail back" students regarding graduation requirements. Guidance regarding the phase-out of the LPT is provided in INFORMATIONAL SUPTS. MEMO. NO. 68 dated May 8, 1998. PURGING OF MIDDLE SCHOOL GRADES A number of questions have been raised about the following language which is found in 8 VAC 20-131-90 D of the standards: In any high school credit-bearing course taken in middle school, parents may request that grades be omitted from the student's transcript and the student not earn high school credit for the course. Notice of this provision must be provided to parents with a deadline and format for making such a request. The standard allows a middle school student to have a high school credit course grade removed from his or her transcript. It was presumed that the student had gone through the entire course and taken any related end-of-course SOL test before having a grade removed. Otherwise, there would be no grade to remove from the record. This is different from the process where local school divisions implement procedures for dropping courses or changing students' schedules during the school year. Localities are to determine the procedures for handling requests and removing a grade from the student's record. These procedures should not allow the student to circumvent the SOL testing requirements. Localities also should determine whether or not the student must repeat the course if the grade is purged. Students may not earn credit for a course based solely on passing a related end-of-course SOL test. Meeting the objectives of the course is implied along with receiving the requisite number of instructional hours. Students who pass a related end-of-course SOL test will not be required to retake the test to earn verified credit if they are required to repeat a course in which the grade has been purged from the student's record. It is recommended that the policy governing this process stipulate that it be completed prior to the beginning of the fall term of the next school year. WAIVERS OF THE STANDARDS The accrediting standards contain provisions that would allow school divisions to request waivers to certain standards. The Board of Education has established the following policies and procedures governing the conditions upon which school divisions may apply for approval of such waivers: 1. Standard School Year and School Day (8 VAC 20-131-150) This regulation requires that schools operate a minimum of 180 instructional days or 990 instructional hours per school year. The regulation requires a minimum of 54 hours of instruction per day in grades 1-12 and a minimum of 3 hours per day for kindergarten. School boards may request approval of an alternative plan to meet these minimums; however, no plan that reduces these requirements can be approved. Local boards do not have to seek approval to exceed the requirements of the standard. 2. Procedures for Certifying Accreditation Eligibility (8 VAC 20-131-290 D relating to Experimental and Innovative Programs) This regulation allows school boards to apply for approval of experimental or innovative programs that are "not consistent with the accrediting standards or other regulations of the Board." The Board may grant approval of such programs for up to five years; however, the regulations prohibit the Board from granting waivers to requests that do not meet the requirements of 8 VAC-20- 131-30 - Student Achievement Expectations, 8 VAC 20-131-50 - Requirements for Graduation, 8 VAC 20-131-70 - Program of Instruction and Learning Objectives, and/or 8 VAC 20-131-280 through 340 - School Accreditation. The Board has adopted the following definitions for experimental and innovative programs: "An experimental program shall be a program which is operated under controlled circumstances and which is designed to test and to establish, by objective measures, the positive cognitive effect of an educational theory." "An innovative program shall be a program shown to produce a positive educational effect but which does not meet standard operating or procedural requirements." 3. Waivers - Generally (8 VAC 20-131-330) Prior to the 1997 revisions, the standards included waiver provisions only for alternative staffing plan requests, alternative schedules, and experimental/innovative programs. Such requests were required to be submitted to the Department of Education for review. The new standards include language that allows waivers of any of the provisions except those related to student academic achievement. An application form has been developed for school divisions to use to apply for waivers under any of the above provisions. The application is attached. Requests for waivers must be submitted at least 90 days prior to the implementation of any proposed program or activity for which a waiver is needed. The Board will review applications at regularly scheduled meetings. Two reviews are normally required, but the Board may waive the first review and approve or disapprove requests on the first reading. The Board typically does not meet in August or December so it is important to allow sufficient lead time between the submission of the request and the anticipated implementation date. I hope these interpretations are helpful as you prepare for the 1998-99 school year. If you have questions, please contact Charles W. Finley at (804) 225-2747, or by e-mail to cfinley@pen.k12.va.us. PDS/cwf Attachment: A hard of this memo and its attachments will be sent to the superintendent's office. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ATTACHMENT TO INTERPRETIVE SUPTS. MEMO. NO. 2 July 24, 1998 SA.020 5/98 (Revised) COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA BOARD OF EDUCATION RICHMOND, VIRGINIA REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF CERTAIN ACCREDITING STANDARDS Regulations Establishing Standards for Accrediting Public Schools in Virginia, (8 VAC 20-131-10 et. seq.) set the minimum standards public schools must meet to be accredited by the Board of Education. Accreditation of public schools is required by the Standards of Quality (22.1-253.13:1 et. seq.). The annual accrediting cycle for public schools is July 1 through June 30. This cover sheet, with the supporting documentation, must be submitted to the Department of Education for review and recommendation to the Board at least 90 days prior to the beginning of an accrediting cycle or the proposed implementation of the program or activity that precipi- tates the request for the waiver. The types of waivers available and the corresponding section of the standards are indicated below. Please feel free to attach additional sheets or information deemed appropriate. SCHOOL DIVISION TITLE OF PROGRAM/ACTIVITY TYPE OF WAIVER REQUESTED: [ ] Approval of an Alternative to the Standard School Year and School Day (8 VAC 20-131-150) [ ] Approval of an Experimental Program (8 VAC 20-131-290 D) [ ] Approval of an Innovative Program (8 VAC 20-131-290 D) [ ] Approval of a Waiver of Other Provision(s) of the Standards (8 VAC 20-131-330) SCHOOL(S) INVOLVED IN THE PROPOSED PROGRAM/ACTIVITY ______________________________ __________________________________ Date Approved Signature by the Local School Board Chairman of the Local School Board ______________________________ __________________________________ Submission Date Signature Division Superintendent -------------------------------------------------------------------------- SA.020 5/98 (Revised) Page 2 SCHOOL DIVISION TITLE OF PROGRAM/ACTIVITY IF THE PROGRAM IS EXPERIMENTAL OR INNOVATIVE, EXPLAIN WHY. IF THE PROGRAM IS EXPERIMENTAL, INCLUDE INFORMATION THAT EXPLAINS WHY THERE IS REASON TO EXPECT THAT THE PROGRAM WILL WORK. DESCRIBE THE RATIONALE FOR AND THE OBJECTIVES OF THE REQUEST FOR A WAIVER. DESCRIBE THE ANTICIPATED OUTCOMES OF THE PROGRAM. TITLE OF PROGRAM/ACTIVITY DESCRIBE THE PROCEDURES THAT WILL BE USED TO EVALUATE THE PROGRAM/ACTIVITY'S EFFECTIVENESS (Include information that includes measurable goals, objectives, and student academic achievement that will be expected as a result of the implementation of the program/ activity). Number of Students Involved in the Program What is the anticipated length of the program? LIST THE REGULATIONS FROM WHICH YOU REQUIRE WAIVERS IN ORDER TO OPERATE THE PROGRAM OR ACTIVITY AND A STATEMENT INDICATING WHY RELEASE FROM THE REGULATION IS NECESSARY. Questions should be directed to Charles W. Finley, Principal Specialist for Policy Analysis, Department of Education at (804) 225-2747 or by e-mail to cfinley@pen.k12.va.us. This application and supporting documentation must be sent to: Superintendent of Public Instruction Department of Education P. O. Box 2120 Richmond, VA 23218-2120