SUPTS. MEMO. NO. 127
July 25, 1997 |
TO: | Division Superintendents |
FROM: | Richard T. La Pointe
Superintendent of Public Instruction |
SUBJECT: | Accuracy of Net Content Labeling of Dairy and Juice Products |
The United States Department of Agriculture Food and Consumer Service (FCS) in conjunction with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the Department of Commerce's National Institute of Standards and Technology, the Office of Food Labeling of the Food and Drug Administration and State weights and measures representatives are participating in a joint federal-state monitoring and education effort designed to focus on the accuracy of content labeling of dairy and juice products across the country. The monitoring phase of the project was conducted in 20 states in April 1997 by state weights and measures representatives. Virginia did not participate in this project. The FTC recently issued a report on the results of the monitoring phase of this project which the FCS anticipates may be widely publicized, particularly in view of the substantial failure rate of dairy and juice products tested in both schools and the retail market. Slightly less than one-half of all lots tested in schools failed; while almost one-third of lots tested in the retail market and at dairies failed. According to the report, state weights and measures representatives tested the net contents of more than 1,600 lots of dairy and juice products in schools, federal and state institutions, retail outlets and dairies. Approximately 760 of the lots were tested in schools, with over 360 of these lots failing. The remainder of the tests were conducted in federal and state institutions, retail outlets and dairies. While the amount of the short weight appears to be quite small in some cases, in others, it is significant. In all cases where a tested lot failed, the amount of the shortage was greater than permitted under established testing procedures. On July 16, 1997, FCS issued a letter to each supplier that provided dairy and juice products to schools which failed to contain the required quantities. The letter expresses FCS serious concerns with the short weighting events, requires the supplier to take corrective actions to remedy the deficiencies that caused the short weighting and provide restitution, within three (3) weeks from the receipt of the letter, to the schools that received short-weighted product. Virginia schools were not tested. So there should be no instances where restitution is due a Virginia school. Because FCS is seriously concerned with the failure of suppliers to provide schools with dairy and juice products which contain the required minimum quantities, FCS has also issued the following recommendations: School food authorities (SFAs) should: 1. Include in all contracts for dairy, juice and other products, a provision that products obtained under contract may be tested by state weights and measures representatives and the remedies that the SFA will exercise when products fail to meet either contract or label specifications. At a minimum these remedies should include: a. Cash restitution or in-kind replacement, at the SFA's discretion, for the total lot which failed; b. Payment for the value of all meals that the SFA served which failed to contain the minimum quantities and components required of a reimbursable meal under the Child Nutrition Programs because the supplier provided short-weighted products; c. The timeframes for providing restitution and payments to the SFA; d. A notice that repeated instances of products failing to contain required quantities is a material breach of the contract which may result in contract termination for cause; e. A requirement that all costs resulting from termination for cause must be borne by the contractor. 2. Invite state weights and measures representatives to conduct tests on the net contents of dairy, juice and other products purchased for use in Child Nutrition Programs. 3. Immediately notify suppliers, in writing, via certified mail or Federal Express, when products fail tests conducted by state weights and measures representatives and direct the supplier to replace the product in cash or in-kind replacement and issue any other funds payable to the SFA pursuant to the terms and conditions established in the contract. 4. Exercise contract termination for cause provisions in a timely manner. 5. Utilize the services of legal counsel to ensure bid, contract terms, and all correspondence with suppliers are legally sufficient and in the best interests of the SFA. In addition to the recommendations outlined above, FCS will use the information obtained through the project to identify additional actions that SFAs can take to improve the integrity of these programs. Since these dairy and juice products are federal nonprocurement program transactions, FCS will also take whatever administrative actions are necessary to protect the public interest and the federal government. Please contact School Nutrition Programs Office at (804) 225-2074 for additional information. RTL/idl